Thursday, February 4, 2010

MTV...Music Television or Reality Television?


The other day, I was determined to get a quick workout in. For me, the only thing that keeps me on the treadmill long enough is watching and listening to music videos. So of course I turned it to MTV (you know the Music Television channel) and to my chagrin, Teen Mom was on. Instinctively, I turned it to VH1 (you know the Music First channel) only to find that a rerun of For the Love of Ray J was on. As my last resort, I turned it to BET (you know the Black Entertainment channel) and Monica: Still Standing was on.

After my unsuccessful music channel quest, I was no longer in the mood to exercise. I got off of the treadmill and sat on the couch. As I sat there, I began to ponder on how reality television has progressively dominated music channels. Ever since MTV cancelled TRL (the Total Request Live show that counted down the top music videos), MTV has not been the same. Similarly, VH1 has been on a music hiatus and instead both channels have been on a reality television rampage. Nearly every month, they are advertising the premiere of a new reality show. Members of one show are offered their own show and it is a never-ending cycle of reality shows. Of the 24 hours in a day, I'd say MTV and VH1 now only devote about 3 hours to actually playing music videos. If my calculations are correct, that leaves virtually 21 hours of non-stop reality television.

As a devoted viewer, left with no other options, I have become addicted to reality television! My addiction began after one dose of an episode of the first season of VH1’s hit show, Flavor of Love. I could not believe that 20 single young women were genuinely seeking love from a played out 50 year old rapper still sporting a gigantic clock around his neck! To my surprise, I found guilty pleasure in watching these women embarrass themselves on national television.


One of the unforgettable episodes was called “The Flavor of Chicken.” In this particular episode, the ladies met Flavor Flav’s mother (why she agreed to be on the show, I do not know!). Of course the ladies had to be on their best behavior in order to make a good first impression –but some did not quite get the memo! The challenge was for the ladies to cook Flav’s mother fried chicken, her favorite dish. “Hottie” (Flav did the honor of assigning each contestant a delicate nickname) cooks her chicken in the microwave. She thought that button on the microwave that read “chicken” meant that it would cook the entire chicken. Bear in mind, she is a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania. Evidently, the ignorance, stupidity, and suspense of shows such as Flavor of Love leave me wanting more!

Essentially, my frustration for MTV, VH1, and BET’s lack of music has not made me completely dislike the channels. Instead it has instilled in me a newfound love for reality television. Nontheless, it has left me a bit disappointed. Quite frankly, MTV and VH1 have lost their authenticity and defeated the purpose of their missions as music channels. Granted they have put out over five different channels devoted solely to music (such as MTV Jams), these channels are not available on basic cable. Thus, I have to pay extra to be able to enjoy what the original channel should have already been doing. In my eyes, like a drug, the spread of reality television is entertaining for the moment but detrimental in the long run! It leaves me to wonder when it will cease.

6 comments:

  1. There are many blogs about reality television and most of them blindly follow whatever celebrity or show they’re focused on. I like your blog idea because you’re choosing to analyze reality television. In a sense you’ve chosen to examine what exactly “reality” even means in the modern day. Last time I checked, club hopping in a limousine or competing for the adoration of some fallen star was not reality. Once you move a few arbitrarily chosen strangers into a mansion, then add alcohol and a hot tub, you’ve lost touch with reality. When I think about it even the term “reality television” seems to be an oxymoron.
    I know I’m going to sound like an old lady, but I seriously wonder how shows like Jersey Shore and Teen Mom could be anything but negative for younger generations. You see, the sad thing about reality television is that it could have awesome social influence (in a positive way). It could have been used as a revolutionary tool. Learning about real people and their circumstances can be inspiring. Instead of trying to make the world a better, healthier place channels like MTV and VH1 promote the opposite.
    How much of the world and its people do we miss out on when the only shows on television focus on fights, hook ups, and petty drama. What happens is reality television, which should be showing us all the big picture, instead perpetuates looking at the world through a peep hole.
    Reality television shows a fashionable and expensive picture, the very capitalist definition of cool. Although money is never mentioned it’s always in the background, gleaming behind bottle blonds and expensive cars. Visual whispers, spend, spend, and spend frivolously. That is, if you want to have as much fun as Ray or look this cool as LC. Instead of a positive social force, reality television has become peer pressure at its worst and I think it’s very cool that you’re choosing to say something about it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am not too sure whether or not I agree with your belief that MTV/VH1 no longer retain their musical roots by only broadcasting reality TV. Instead, I think MTV/VH1 has found a new way to reach their target audience in order to play new music. While music videoes and TRL are no longer present on the networks, someone who is a fan of a certain song now has so many ways to listen to it. For example, a person could go onto itunes, youtube, or the celebrities website to watch the video. It's similar to how singers know that album sales don't generate as much money as they used too so now they rely on concerts. Whenever I watched an episode of "Jersey Shore," the title of a song and the album it appeared on was present on the bottom of the screen as it played. When the show ended, there is usually a web address one could go too in order to buy the album.

    I think MTV/VH1 is capitalizing on the success of reality TV in order to broadcast music. Reality TV is cheap to produce and generates good ratings from their target audience, the 21-49 age group. Furthermore, as you said, music videos could still be found on their premium cable channels. Wouldn't that just be more incentive for you to purchase them?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well I'm going to jump on the bandwagon and be the third one to post on this. I like where your heading with the blog, and it kind of makes me wonder why we, as a society, have such a fascination with voyeurism.

    Do you think the reason MTV is a big in the market because of its age demographic? Or is there something about music itself that enhances the experience. I know that for a lot of people, music strikes a certain chord, and people begin to relate...even break down social walls. Maybe it's a good medium because of this very fact.

    I know sports for me helps break the initial social awkwardness. Coincidence that HBO sports runs an NFL reality show on training camp?

    I can offer a bit of personal experience here and see if it provides you any insight. I was out at a bar while MTV's "Real World" cast was filming, and actually had a chance to hang out with the cast for a little bit back at their house (No, you will not see me on night vision necking it, sorry to disappoint).

    Essentially what I got from the experience was this surreal atmosphere where pop culture was almost a living breathing entity in front of me. It was wild.

    It's weird to think that the self feeding engine of reality television, as an almost a reflection of what we want. The ratings are so high for these shows, because we LOVE them. We feed off of drama, chaos, love, violence, and alcohol.

    Anyways, keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I completely agree with your remarks in this blog. I, too, remember the days of Total Request Live and the endless hours of music video blocks. However, we are far from that now. I hate to admit this, but I remember the days when I would turn on MTV while bored, and much to my dismay there would be a block of music videos that I really could care less for.

    I will whole-heartedly admit that I am one of those people who calls MTV’s reality shows guilty pleasures. I am an avid Real World follower, and have been known to have occasional viewing parties to discuss the crazy happenings on the show.

    I also like the fact that you touched base on MTV’s other channels devoted to certain types of music. Though I applaud MTV’s efforts to keep some of it’s original mission statement in tact, I think it is quite ridiculous that this requires the network to produce separate stations. These separate stations are not easily accessible, and they still do not achieve the appeal of the original MTV lineup.

    Do you think that MTV is smart for creating these alternative music video stations? Or do you think they are a failed attempt to please music-loving audiences? Personally, I think it’d be more beneficial for MTV to have a more even distribution in their programming schedule. For instance, they should include equal amounts of music video blocks and reality television shows in order to try to please a wider audience. However, it is important to take demographics into consideration. I’m sure that the population of viewers today is a lot different than those viewing in 1981 when MTV first aired.

    I enjoyed reading your blog because it is definitely a topic that everyone can relate to. I’m sure the majority of the U.S. population that owns a TV has seen a reality television show of some sort, and has been pulled into its addictive-nature.

    ReplyDelete
  5. First, I’d like to commend you on this blog, it’s well written and your topic choice is awesome. I’m really excited to see where it goes.

    I’d like to post a link to what I think is a very relevant question posted on Yahoo! Answers about a month ago: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100102194537AAGApJy

    If you don’t feel like going to the website, the question simply asks: “Why do people love Jersey Shore so much?” “Jersey Shore” being the smash television sensation that’s bringing MTV as much if not more revenue than “Bevis and Butthead” did when it was originally aired 17 years ago on our beloved “Music Television”.
    The first answer (and the only real answer that one would need) to that question was the first one posted, “Because their stupidity is actually pretty impressive.”

    For whatever reason, us as human beings are attracted to idiocy. Whether we’re bottlenecking at the scene of an “accidental” fender bender between a stupid teenager texting and driving and some old guy waggling his finger at them telling them off for being dumb, or watching it from the comfort of our own living rooms. We love to watch people screw up and say ridiculous things. And while music trends are difficult and take time to track (even for corporations with as much money and manpower as MTV has) stupidity is relatively consistent and universal. That is why I figure it’s just more cost-effective for music channels to just make the switch to all nonsense, all the time.

    I would also like to mention that it was in the news recently that MTV has dropped, “Music Television” from it’s logo (see the article here: http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/showtracker/2010/02/mtv-drops-music-television-from-its-logo.html) It’s truly a wonder that anyone noticed the change at all, seeing as how we’re too busy watching “Guidos” fist-pump and beat the beat at local Jersey hot spots. Like the article said, the current MTV generation does not hold the same emotional value for the logo as did the previous. It’s a shame that even music stations like Fuse (my favorite throughout my high school days with amazing shows like “Steven’s Untitled Rock Show”) who started out so hopeful with MTV bashing slogans like “where music went” and “where music lives” have even made the switch to some easier to digest TV shows for the general public.

    WITH THAT BEING SAID, Fuse is still an excellent source for new music/music videos.
    And I love “Jersey Shore”.

    ReplyDelete