
Many people feel that reality television is not real. With the exception of a few documentary based shows, they feel that all of these shows are scripted to enhance drama and I do not doubt that. However, I do not think that is enough reasoning to completely dismiss reality television as being real. In my opinion, reality shows are not entirely, but rather partially real. They document a modified form of reality. Although the participants are placed in abnormal situations and in unordinary locations, these shows feature ordinary people and actual occurrences.
Reality television does not implement professional actors as its participants. The participants featured on these shows are everyday people, like you and I. Aside from fifteen minutes of fame and maybe a few bucks on the side, these people do not get much out of exploiting themselves on national television. Many of them genuinely come on these shows and behave how they would in their daily lives. Some of us find these behaviors to be rehearsed and scripted because they tend to be uncultivated and outlandish. However, we live in a society where some people genuinely act like this on a regular basis. For these participants, there just happens to be a camera to capture it. Special-living environment documentary shows like the Bad Girls Club and the Real World tend to always portray various acts of physical and verbal violence. Is that unrealistic? When 6 or more people from various walks of life are moved into one house, is everyone naturally going to get along? Of course not! Think of your freshman year in college, when you were randomly assigned a roommate. You all probably clashed on several occasions. It may not have necessarily lead to physical violence, but demeaning words sure may have been exchanged.
Realistically speaking, there are people that engage in outrageous behavior and their behavior is even more enhanced when there is an audience. For these reality show participants, we are there audience. So of course, to make the show interesting, they may overreact a bit to make the show more interesting. Nonetheless, naturally, people go above and beyond to please whatever audience they may have. For instance, in a fight, a person who is normally nonviolent but is being bullied and does not want to appear as a punk, may go above and beyond to beat their opponent up, just to prove to his audience that he or she is indeed not a punk! For these reality stars, they show off a pinch more to boost ratings or in the hopes of becoming famous. We all have done it, at one point in time!
In using these ordinary people, reality shows are able to document actual occurrences. Being that these are ordinary people, they do have emotions and in doing these shows they tend to respond to situations accordingly. For instance, on dating-competition based shows like Flavor of Love and For the Love of Ray J, these women come in with the mindset that they are going to do whatever they have to, to win the guy’s heart. Thus, a natural female tendency kicks in. As any other woman would, these female participants get jealous at the sight of their man flirting with another female. They are ready to fight for what they believe is rightfully theirs. As I previously mentioned, the violence that erupts on special-living environment shows tend to result from built up frustration, which leads to the hair-grabbing, sucker punching, pushing, and kicking. Essentially, the physical fights, the arguments, the crying, the hook-ups, etc are all actual occurences. I do not think that video editors are able to concoct and produce such scenes using editing equipment!
Essentially, reality television is not completely forged, it is partially real. These shows involve ordinary people partaking in actual occurrences. Despite the fact that the living arrangments and situations that the people are in may not be ordinary, these people are still acting like their normal selves. It is not out of the ordinary to see people act in outlandish and indecent ways. Such sights can be witnessed at college parties or while you are walking down the streets. Naturally, people show off more when there is an audience, but that does not make their actions unreal!
While I agree (for the most part) with your thesis, I have some opposing examples that I'd like to contribute and see if your thesis stays the same. You mention a number of what you called "special living environment" shows, and in regards to those examples I think what you argue is extremely valid. However, shows like Next (on MTV), for instance, make me think otherwise. I find myself consistently questioning the contestants on these shows-whether or not the things coming out of their mouths are their actual words or something scripted by the producers. Normally, I believe it's the latter of the two, because the phrases are so overly-witty and pathetic that I do not believe people would talk like that in reality. I absolutely could be wrong on that one, and I know it isn't fair to make assumptions, but the scripting is just out of control. Unfortunately I don't have any specific examples, but the phrases that come out of these contestants' mouths are just ridiculous. In this example in particular, I believe that reality is severely altered. Yes, the contestants could be picking the contestant they truly like most, but the things they are saying persuade me to believe the reality of the situation is obscured. Are you familiar with this show? If so, how do you feel it portrays reality?
ReplyDeleteI always love reading your blog because I tend to side with you on every argument you make. I am a reality TV nut... I love the Real World especially... and yes, although I am one of those people who believes reality TV is altered to a certain degree, I still find actuality in the shows I watch.
I think you did a great job relating this post to your audience. Referring to college students moving into a dorm with an unknown roommate is definitely something that I, and others I'd assume, can relate to. You consistently know how to draw your readers into your blog postings, so good job :]
I am more in agreement with your latest post on your blog than not. The reason is because I tend to be a personality myself, there is just not a camera following me around to see half the dumb crap I do just to entertain myself. I look at my own story, and if you put me in a dorm of people with various walks of life, I am pretty sure they are going to question the actions and inner motivations of the asian guy who was formerly incarcerated, and whom they are now stuck rooming with.
ReplyDeleteI felt that a stronger argument might have been posed by just stating that crazy things happen in real life that people lable as surreal. Like mass murders, roberries, and just crazy things related to boundary violation and the like in life are more common than not. Just because we find them repeated for a month on the 6 o clock news instead of labled reality television doesn't mean that they are any less "off" occurances in teh world we reside in.
The camera also has an effect on us. You put a camera on some, they straigten up and act as if they are the most well behaved people in the world. To others, it's an oportunity for fame and to go nuts and make a name for themselves. Either way, it's not too far off from the person they are attempting to portray, or the person they might be. Who would know besides the person in that role. If they are in that role, are they in denial anyways?
Overall, I think it's a great question you posed and a nice answer. Maybe more empirical data can give us a better understanding, but for now, it's greeat reality blog posting here!!!
Excellent blog with a great thesis, as always. I completely agree with you on how people may just be over acting and such because they are aware they're on television and that the shows are not entirely scripted.
ReplyDeleteWhat amazes me about the major criticism of reality television is the hypocrisy behind it. People say that the people are acting different and wouldn't do these things in real life, but are they going out day to day and interacting with people who are 100% honest? Of course not. People put on a front and act a different role according to each situation. Thus, how can those same people say reality shows how people really are? For example, when getting calls from telemarketers, do you really believe they are depicting themselves honestly? I say no,m they are putting up a phone personality. They try to act helpful, nice, etc.. when in reality they probably hate their job.
Putting up different personas in different situation is something everyone does every single day. How people accuse reality television for being false for simply showing such a truth bewilders me. If these reality stars are capitalizing being behind a camera, then so be it. I'd rather them bitch someone out and cause a fight than sit back and watch TV all day. How fun would it be to watch people... be... ordinary people?
I think your future blog could analyze the different levels of reality television and show that, even if some try to make themselves seem more "documentaryish," (such as TruTV where their slogan is: Not reality, actuality) they still are just as true/false as MTV reality shows like The Hills, where MTV pays for their apartments and got them awesome jobs.
I've been thinking about the show, and some of the thoughts you've been saying, and I think you need to also include the agenda set forth by MTV. While it is real life people, they're reacting based on their given situation.
ReplyDeleteAlso, Don't forget that the great people over at MTV select the people on the show, after thorough psychological evaluations, and piece together a cast that won't disappoint. Also, as I mentioned before, it's a genuine reflection of what society wants as entertainment.
I think it speaks volumes about a society when we see most reality shows feed off of violence, drama, and comedy. Those factors are hard to resist. Why do so many people slow down at a car wreck? Maybe there are also some evolutionary aspects that are ingrained in our systems that make us want this. Is it such a bad thing?
I really like this blog, and I think that in one aspect, I feel that your drifting a bit when referencing what is reality. However, with such a modern world, where everything technically can be recorded, this may not be too far from the truth.
Keep up the good work, and I hope it turns out well.
I liked this blog topic a alot because all students question whether or not reality television is actually real. Most people I know think it's fake, but you actually argued that Reality television was real(partially) which is even more interesting. Personally, I think it is fake but not scripted. Actors or people on Reality TV know that there is a camera recording them so they may try to draw attention and create more drama in their life. This is why drama is involved with Reality television. I mean they are getting paid to have a camera watching them everyday so they have to make it somewhat entertaining. This brings me to my point that people on reality tv are basically actors because they certainly do not act like themselves if they know everyone is watching them. I believe the camera crew somehow tricks the audience into thinking the footage presented is real. For example, on youtube I saw a video clip proving that Man vs. Wild is a complete lie. Edward Michael Grylls'(the host of Man vs. Wild) body was shown to be in a deserted and barren land then the camera zoomed out and it revealed Grylls to be in a field on a side of a highway. I seriously thought that Edward Michael Grylls was telling the truth whenever he said that he was in a jungle, the mountains, or the desert. But, I guess he is just an actor with a crew that can make adjustments to create a fake scenario which the audience will see as real. Also, I wanted to bring up the show, "For the Love of Ray J". Some girls on that show may not be there for Ray J, but for the fame. They just want the fame and attention. I mean the "love" that they have for Ray J may all be an act just so that they can be on television. This is just what I think, I may be wrong or right. I really enjoyed how you supported the otherside of this debate with your own insights though. I can't wait for your other posts.
ReplyDelete