Thursday, April 1, 2010

EPIPHANY!



As I previously stressed, despite the tastelessness of reality television, I am attracted because such shows are ego boosters and vicarious thrill rides. However, after creating these blogs and conducting my research, I have come to an important realization. The joys I experience from these reality shows, at the expense of these participants’ humiliation, is immoral! As a human being, I have ethical and moral responsibilities (universal responsibilities of human beings regardless of status, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation, etc.). By watching and enjoying such negative reality shows, I am neglecting my human responsibilities in the realm of “fundamental principles of humanity” as well as “justice and solidarity” and promoting immorality.

According to the fundamental principles of humanity, “No person should lend support to any form of inhumane behavior, but all people have a responsibility to strive for the dignity and self-esteem of all others (Article 2).” From the fist fights to the homosexual bashing to the spitting in each others’ faces, inhumane behavior is constantly portrayed on these reality shows. Usually, such drama is what keeps me tuned in. However, by faithfully tuning in, I am only adding to the show’s ratings and subsequently lending support to the callous behaviors exhibited. My support leads these participants to believe that such behavior is acceptable, when indeed it is not. Instead of getting amusement out of these participants’ insecurities and misguided lives, I should be wishing them well-being. I should be hoping that they learn and gain something—other than a black eye—from their experience on the show. As members of this society, we have to work to uplift each other, rather than assassinate each other’s character.

In addition to uplifting one another, we should be striving for justice and solidarity. Accordingly, “All people, given the necessary tools, have a responsibility to make serious efforts to overcome poverty, malnutrition, ignorance, and inequality. They should promote sustainable development all over the world in order to assure dignity, freedom, security and justice for all people.” Unbelievably, many of these shows are set up for it’s participants to change their ways. For instance, the special living environment show, Bad Girls Club, groups 7 self-proclaimed Bad Girls under one roof, but it is unclear what these girls are to take away from this show. You often hear them say that they came to change their ways. However, we see no therapist on the show. We don’t see any effort on the part of the show’s producers to address, head on, the ills that plague these so called bad girls. All we see is an effort to exploit them. Essentially, my continual viewing persuades producers to think that such shows are entertaining and do not need therapists. So, in fulfilling my moral responsibilities, I need to work to overcome this ignorance, instead of promoting it.

Perhaps I should become proactive. I can began a movement towards banning the shows that are solely created to exploit the downtrodden for the sake of a buck. Maybe I can began a boycott to end shows that challenge what should be the moral and social values of society. In this spirit, I could even call and encourage others to call major advertisers of these shows and threaten to boycott their products unless they demand that the reality show networks “clean up” their lineup. [THESE ARE ONLY SUGGESTIONS!]. Nonetheless, the possibilities are endless. Thus, as a maturing young lady, I need to take care of my moral responsibilities responsibilities. Instead of getting pleasure from these participants’ self-destruction, I ought to encourage them to portray themselves with dignity. Essentially, reality television is not fading away anytime soon. So why not shift to more positive gears that do not incorporate the humiliation of others?

*Got responsibilities from...
http://www.interfaithdialoguebasics.be/universal%20declaration%20of%20human%20responsibilities.htm

2 comments:

  1. As someone who watched lots of reality television, I never deemed myself as immoral for doing so. I believe that the side we see of people on television are only a certain side, a part of them in which they think they would be appealing. Also, I consider how "real" some of these shows are. The producers or whatnot may script some scenarios in order to evoke drama. Drama is what sells the shows, and what makes people watch them. If everyone was friendly, drinking tea while discussing how happy they are, then it would simply be boring.

    Speaking of the viewer being immoral... It is not like there is much choice in television these days. Reality television has destroyed the sitcom, as the most popular one "Two and a Half Men" is AWFUL (in my opinion) and its target audience is 50+ year old men. Why should I feel a moral responsibility when I have no choice over the matter? Shouldn't the networks themselves feel immoral for capitalizing the genres success? Furthermore, what can the viewer do to influence the network heads and/or the reality stars? While social networking sites, email, and phone are all viable ways to contact these people, I doubt they are concerned about a stranger's opinion.

    Perhaps it is because I am from New York, which is a giant melting pot, but I avoid judging the people I see on television. As I just said, I don't know if these people only show a certain side or if they were put up to it. Even if Snooki from Jersey Shore is really like how she presented herself on TV, who am I to judge her? I don't put myself on some moral ground where I deem all of my actions moral whereas she is completely immoral. Everyone has their set of rules within his or her own head of what is right and wrong. As long as someone abides to the law and respects others personal space, then I don't judge them.

    I do find it interesting how you mention The Bad Girls Club and how you think they need a therapist. I personally disagree. While someone with the qualifications may give them a psychological perspective as to why they are the way that they are, I believe setting them in a house with people similar to themselves will give them an entirely new perspective. When they see how they act through a third party, they could come to a revelation that their actions are wrong. Furthermore, I am a heavy believer that the more perspectives you share/hear, the better. Even if the girls have blurred morality, hearing what they have to say about one another could give you insight into your character and how you can change. There does not need to be an "official" mentor telling you what to do. Remember, people only change if they want to change. Just if a qualified professional tells me I'm crazy doesn't mean I have to believe him/her.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Victoria, I’m glad that your blog has taken this wonderful turn. I’ve honestly not watched any reality television aside from the show Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County; the only reason that I watched Laguna Beach was that I found Kristin Cavallari to be supremely attractive, and that physical attraction kept my eyes glued to the television. I initially stayed away from watching reality television because I had determined that it was a form of education for those who were less educated, a sentiment that certainly could come across as arrogant. However, after reading your blog, my opinion has changed; there are many important messages sent by reality television shows, and one can certainly watch the shows with a critical eye.

    Not only have you watched the television shows with a critical eye, but you have even made a morality judgment about yourself watching the shows. Such thought would have never occurred to me, and I find it amazing that you were able to view your show-watching habit in such a light; that clearly indicates that you are one of amazing moral character and have tremendous conviction in your beliefs. I completely agree that the portrayal of characters engaging in immoral acts just for the sake of financial gain is very unethical.

    I’ll now state a personal example of the sentiment that you convey. Though I haven’t watched the show, I’ve read that MTV’s Jersey Shore portrays the Tri-State Italian-American community as sex-crazed, uneducated, and frivolous; the girls are depicted as those who merely sleep around and the guys are portrayed as idiotic meatheads. I believe that in watching such a show, one is silently saying that (s)he approves of the stereotype, which would not be true.

    It’s one thing to have a strong set of beliefs and another to have a plan to implement the beliefs. I appreciate that your blog entry provides several suggestions to reform the reality television status quo. I think calling advertisers and threatening for boycott is a fantastic idea; if enough people participate, the message can definitely be sent!

    ReplyDelete