
Hi, my name is Victoria and I am an alcoholic—I mean a voyeur. However, like some alcoholics, I wish to remain anonymous. Who freely wants to be known as an obsessive observer of sordid and sensational subjects? Not me, but the reality is that I am. That is, when it comes to reality television! Of the various genres, to me the most appealing are elimination game shows and self-improvement shows. As far as game shows, I prefer to watch the dating-based competitions versus the skill-based competitions. I faithfully tune into For the Love of Ray J as opposed to Hell’s Kitchen. In regards to self-improvement shows, I prefer Bad Girls Club to The Biggest Loser. Do you notice any commonalities in my preferences? Sad to admit, but I prefer shows that evoke drama, conflict, and ignorance. Despite the distastefulness of such shows, I continue to watch them faithfully because in essence, such shows are ego-boosters and vicarious thrill rides.
As these reality shows progress, the participants get more and more ruthless. Accordingly, watching these shows shields my ego more and more. Sounds funny, I know. However, it correlates with a concept I learned in one of my psychology courses—the social comparison theory. Naturally, many individuals tend to evaluate their own opinions and abilities in comparison to others. There are two main types of comparison—upward and downward. Upward social comparison occurs when individuals compare themselves to others deemed socially above them in some way. [I do not quite see any of these reality shows participants as "socially above me."] On the other hand, downward social comparison is a defensive tendency to evaluate oneself in comparison to a group whose troubles are more serious than one’s own. [Now, this I am guilty of.] Unlike the desperate girls on these dating-based competitions, I do not have trouble finding a man and if I did, I would never resort to competing against 20 others for one person’s heart knowingly and willingly. And unlike the girls on Bad Girls Club, I do not need that much self-improvement. Essentially, reality shows make me feel a tad bit better about my own life and goals; it pleasures my ego to know that I do not have it as bad as some.
Watching reality shows, not only boosts my ego but also sends me on a vicarious thrill ride. Overall, I live a rather conservative and somewhat lackluster life. Thus, at times, I tend to be a bit of a thrill-seeker. Reality shows offer a communal experience. As I watch, I have an imagined participation in the experience; I tend to yell at the television screen or make remarks as if I am actually apart of the show. Usually these participants are engaging in activities that I would not dare engage in—due to my desire to preserve my character. I, personally, would never get debilitating drunk, have a threesome with random people I just met from the club, or purposefully start a physical altercation. However, for those 60 minutes, I am able to do such things. I am able to vicariously live my desirable thrill-seeking life through the participants and take a harmless walk on the wild side.
Frankly, I do not watch reality television with the intent of gaining precious insight into the human condition-that is what the news is for. The shows I enjoy portray people making fools of themselves. For me, these shows provide proof that there are people out there with issues and decision-making skills worse than mine. Of course, this builds on my ego. In addition, participants’ daringness and willingness to humiliate and expose themselves on national television, gives me the opportunity to surreptitiously fulfill my occassional thrill-seeking desires. Through imagined participation, I step into the character of the participants and become apart of the show. As odd as it sounds, to me, reality television is a self-gratifying medium.
*Thanks to Rob for mentioning voyeurism! I never quite thought of it that way until you mentioned it!*
I'm glad and impressed that you decided to look at the factors that draw you to the reality tv shows you like & what that reveals about you. That these shows make you feel better about yourself while letting you relish in the outlandish behaviors of others is interesting. If nobody was judging you, would you like to let loose like the women on these shows? What is the appeal of acting this way? What exactly is holding you back? Solid self and genre analysis!
ReplyDeleteI, too, wonder where these networks find such people as the cast of the "Jersey Shore" or any VH1 reality show (although, its my guilty pleasure watching them, including some of which I'll never admit actually watching and/or enjoying). Like you, I enjoy the genre because it shows the side of people which I find most interesting/entertaining to watch. Watching people flip out, stress out, and do things that are "out of character" makes me grin only because I would hate to be in such a situation and life would not be so entertaining if everyone was so happy/lovey dovey all the time.
ReplyDeleteI do think you touch upon a subject that deserves further exploration. What do you think these reality shows tells us about society if they are become more drama-oriented than game oriented? Originally, the reality show to watch was Survivor, which essentially was a game show. Although other shows came out after wards which drew upon this "game" concept, I believe what made Survivor so popular during season 1 was the absolutely foul Richard Hatch (ew) and how Susan completely bitched out Kelly at tribal council (if you have not watched this, Youtube it. It's hilarious). Shows such as "Housewives of..." and "Jersey Shore" have drifted from the whole concept of winning something to only showing how certain people act. I believe the reality show genre has shifted focus because the shows that have good ratings are the ones with the most hostile/drama-evoking characters. People do have some interest in watching others do extraordinary things to win money, but I think people would rather prefer watching a full out brawl instead of everyone playing nice.
What I did find interesting about your blog is how you compare their social standing to your own. I never really thought about it, but I believe that everyone seems to do this on some sort of level. While watching Jersey Shore, I could not help but wonder how Snooki’s parents must feel watching their daughter speak about wanting to bone any man with a semi-functional penis. From watching the show, I concluded that I must have had a rather normal upbringing because I did not turn out as delusional as “The Situation” or as desperate for attention as Snooki. But, by making these comparisons, I must have made some judgment of their character based off the little bits of their lives that was broadcasted. Do you think this social comparison is what made the show so popular? That MTV and other networks are trying to look for more and more outrageous characters so people feel a bit better about their rather mundane lives?